Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge-same great taste you love as ice cream in a creamy melt in your mouth fudge!
One of the easiest candies to make is fudge. There are several recipes out there but basically there are 2 camps. Fudge made with marshmallow fluff and fudge made with sweetened condensed milk. They are both equally good recipes.
I usually go with the sweetened condensed milk. Mainly because as much as I love the marshmallow fluff version, the sweetened condensed milk is faster and easier. No candy thermometer, no standing over the stove. Melt some chocolate chips, decide on a flavor, press into your pan and a few hours later you are eating your fudge!
This time of year, my freezer space is at a premium. I’m baking ahead for the holidays. There might be a turkey in there. I pick up meats when there’s a good sale and stock up. And did I mention the 170 pounds of unshelled pecans I bought last week? My girls have done awesome cleaning them and getting them bagged up. I won’t have 170 pounds of shelled pecans when they’re done but I’ll still have a ton of pecans. So far, I’ve frozen 10 gallon bags worth. And they’re not done yet.
So I need to make room. It’s amazing what you find in the back of the freezer when you have to clean it out. We might have had a smorgasbord of appetizers that night for dinner. Pizza rolls, hot pockets, taquitos, french fries. All those almost empty bags and boxes. No one complained.
Then there was the ice cream. Yes, I found 4 almost empty half gallon containers. All different flavors. When the weather cools off, you forget about the ice cream. Sadly there was none of my favorite, Mint Chocolate Chip. The kids suffered through eating up the ice cream too. (The sacrifices they make for me.) I got to craving my Mint Chocolate Chip. So I made it into a fudge.
And it’s amazing. And addicting. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Connect with Chocolate Chocolate and More!
Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge
Ingredients
Instructions
Want more Fudge?
White Chocolate Fudge with Cranberries and Pistachios
Buckeye Fudge from Barefeet in the Kitchen
Key Lime Fudge from Recipegirl
Winter White Red Velvet Fudge from The Cafe Sucre Farine
I love fudge this time of year, and mint chip is my favorite ice cream, so this is awesome!
I am such a sucker for mint chocolate! I wouldn’t mind a few of these!
Thanks so much for the link Joan. Your fudge looks fabulous. This would be a huge hit with my family too!
I usually go w/ sweetened condensed milk as well although I just tried something new with fudge and according Hubs it’s a winner. This Mint fudge looks yummy, love the color!
Paula, will you share the difference you made that Hubby like better. Thank you!
This is fantastic, LOVE!!!
Why is peppermint an absolute NO? Does it affect the recipe? Not taste right?
If you use peppermint extract it will taste like peppermint and nothing like Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream, there is a huge difference in the flavor. I just don’t want readers expecting one flavor then tasting another.
I just made this fudge according to the recipe and it tastes like toothpaste. 🙁 I’m so disappointed in this.
I thought it tasted like gum. So did my co-workers. Wasn’t a big hit. I’ll try peppermint next time.
Agreed, tasted like gum. My consistency was not like fudge either. I let it cool for hours and never really set up, even put it in the freezer. 🙁
Hmmm…. how about peppermint extract and red food coloring??? Peppermint fudge!!
Absolutely! And you could crush some candy canes and sprinkle them on top.
So, do you use spearmint? Or is there a regular ‘mint’ flavoring (because if so, i can’t find it around me)
Can this be frozen? I am going to make it regardless, but it would be nice to freeze some:)
Yes we often freeze our whole tray of fudge because its easier to cut (after you let it sit for a few of course) 🙂 food luck I just made this fudge tonight but I didn’t wait long enough to add the chocolate chips so they made a swril 🙂
can you freeze fudge, how far ahead can you make it? Thank You
Honestly, I’ve never frozen Fudge but on my next batch, I’ll throw a few pieces in the freezer and see how it does.
oooooh-Michael LOVES mint choc chip ice cream (and I don’t think it’s too shabby either) so this fudge would go over like gangbusters at our house!
I’m having trouble finding ‘mint’ extract. I can find peppermint…but not just plain mint. Any suggestions?
This time of year I see it everywhere, I usually pick it up at Walmart, 3 bottles at a time.
I have a question, I only know about peppermint extract.can you tell me a brand or what mint extract is made from?Thanx kim
I use McCormick Mint Extract, also Watkins has a good one.
These look absolutely amazing Joan! Fudge is such a perfect holiday gift and mint chocolate is even a festive flavor!! I can’t wait to try! Pinned! 🙂
What a fun recipe, Joan! I adore mint chip ice cream and this has my name all over it. Thanks for the link to my fudge as well!
My other half is looking forward to this treat & is bugging me to make them now but I don’t have white chocolate chips or mint extract … Would mint chocolate chips work?
They sure would!
Can I use creme de menthe instead of the mint extract? I Have a lot of it and don’t know what to do with it…
Yes you can, just be sure to warn your consumers that there is booze in it as your Creme de Menthe will be full strength in alcohol content.
Do you sell the finished product and ship?
I’m sorry I don’t sell it.
I know it will affect the colour, but how would just using regular chocolate chips affect the taste? I love mint chocolate but I hate white chocolate…
Chocolate Mint Fudge will taste amazing!
Can you use semisweet chocolate chips instead of the white chocolate chips? I don’t keep white chocolate on hand.
Yes you can but of course your fudge won’t be green and you’ll have a chocolate mint fudge, still delicious!
Looks tasty! If I make them for holiday gifts, how long can they be kept outside the fridge? I’m from Australia and it’s really hot right now.
Once the fudge is set, there’s no need to keep this in the fridge unless your home is very hot.
Hi I can’t seem get mint extract. Can use dried mint?
You can but you’ll have little flakes of the dried mint that might be too strong. You can make a mint extract of your own if you have the dried mint. Place the dried mint in a small bottle or sealable jar then add vodka to cover the mint. Similar to how you make vanilla Extract.
Looks amazing! Could you please tell me how much this makes? Thanks in advance!
It depends on how large you cut your squares. If you are cutting 1 inch squares, you’ll get 64 pieces.
Looks delicious! How many servings does this recipe make?
That depends on how large you cut your squares. If you cut into 1 inch squares, you’ll get 64 pieces.
Well I tried and I failed. I put the chocolate chips and butter in the microwave as instructed but it took much longer than quoted. It got to a point where the chunks were gone but it was like a paste. Figured that was what was meant (fudge is thick so it makes sense lol). Tried to mix it all together and got a nasty, oily, greasy mess. Nothing mixed together.
Lesson learned, next time I will melt it over boiling water to make sure it’s more “liquid” and try again.
I’m so sorry my directions weren’t more clear. you want to melt the chocolate and butter just until the butter is melted. You’ll still have lumps of chocolate chips. After removing from the microwave and stirring, the remaining lumps should melt.
I got the same oily mixture after I added the peppermint and colouring. As I kept stirring, more and more oil / butter came out of the mixture. Maybe I should have heated it back up to combine? The goo tastes good.
This shouldn’t have been oily at all. Did you check the measurements? Also make sure your chocolate is completely melted before adding in the sweetened condensed milk.
It’s probably from overcooking the chocolate. It’s easy to do in the microwave…
Well, Chris, you’re not alone. Mine was a failure too. First, I “overmelted” the chocolate because I was expecting, well, melted chocolate…not softened chocolate lumps. Then, since I couldn’t find mint extract locally, I had bought it from amazon and it was oil based not alcohol or water based. Then, I didn’t have any green food coloring (apparently I had two bottles of blue and these old eyes thought the lighter one was green!) so I mixed yellow and blue food coloring. Don’t believe the color theorists and artists…blue and yellow doesn’t really make green! I don’t have a name for the color it made but, it doesn’t make any difference because I added the mini chips too soon and they melted! So I have a batch of muddy brown fudge. It does tast good though! Go ahead and have a good belly laugh…I did!
Is it OK to leave the food coloring out? I’m assuming the color won’t be green but the flavor should still be OK?
Of course you can leave it out. The food coloring is like with the ice creams, people are just used to seeing the green color.
What would the swap be from sweetened condensed milk to marshmallow cream?
I have no idea, the fudge recipe using marshmallow cream is completely different and also requires a candy thermometer. This Eggnog Fudge uses the marshmallow cream if you’d like to see an example. https://chocolatechocolateandmore.com/2012/11/eggnog-fudge/
When you store it in the air tight container, do you put it in the fridge afterwards or leave it on a counter?
This fudge does not need to be refrigerated.
Is this fudge suitable for mailing? I noted it must be refrigerated to set up. After it sets up initially, does it get too soft if left at room temp (in which case not suitable for mailing)?
Once the fudge is set, it doesn’t need to be kept in the refrigerator. Yes you can mail it. This fudge will keep for at least 2 weeks.
Can I use green creme de menthe instead of the mint extract and food coloring?
I like the way you think, Yes you can!
Hi can I do same but with vanilla? As trying do it for someone else but they not fond of mint? Many thanks
Sure you can use vanilla. I’d recommend only using 1-2 teaspoons of vanilla extract.
I’ve just made mine with vanilla as I couldn’t find mint anywhere. I made it pink instead of green too so fingers crossed it tastes yummy when I get it out of the fridge! 🙂
I’m sure it will taste delish!
are the white choc. and mini choc chips supposed to be regular or semi sweet? making friday so i need to know soon
The white chocolate chips are just regular, I use Nestle white Chocolate chips and the mini chips are also Nestle semi-sweet chocolate chips. Feel free to use your favorite brand.
do use sweetened or semi sweet chocolate chips and salted or unsalted butter?
The chips are semi-sweet and I always use unsalted butter.
What flavor of mini chocolate chips do you use? Semi-sweet, dark, milk chocolate? Thanks!
I use Semi-sweet but use whatever you like.
you omitted the third camp -old fashioned fudge, which is cooked to soft-ball stage, cooled, and beaten until it starts to set.
Also, most fudges that use marshmallow don’t need a thermometer. You cook it 5 minutes, then stir in the chocolate and marshmallows (or fluff). Almost as easy as the condensed milk kind, and I like the taste better.
Good coloring can’t be the liquid kind, correct? Gel or paste. Just verifying so I make sure I do this right. I think I tried the liquid before and it doesn’t work with white chocolate. Can’t wait to try this!
I have many different brands of food coloring in my baking cabinet, for this recipe I used the Betty Crocker Gel food Coloring that you can find in the grocery stores or at Walmart Betty Crocker Classic Gel Food Colors – 4 CT
“>
I melted the white chocolate chips first then mixed in the condensed milk. But once I stirred in the mini chocolate chips, the mix no longer had the nice green color. It just looks like regular chocolate. What happened? I put quite a few drops of food coloring first and it was a nice shade of green until added the regular chocolate chips.
You need to let the fudge cool a bit before adding in the chocolate chocolate chips or they will melt into the mixture. Sorry this happened to you, I’m sure it still tasted great!
Weird question but it popped in my head while I was reading about people having issues with it separating and being oily. My sister told me “butter” in southern regions is margarine. So you should be using real butter and not margarine right? I NEVER cook or bake with margarine always real butter but i have to wonder if that’s what’s causing the oilyness and separation when people prepare the white chocolate and the butter. Another thing I just thought of is if your microwave is hot (meaning it’s been used for long periods of time without cooling between uses) things will cook/melt a lot faster so make sure to watch it carefully. Burned a whole 12oz batch of chocolate in less than 2 mins cause I didn’t let the microwave cool.
I only use real unsalted butter for all my recipes. You’re right, margarine can behave different in recipes and it varies so much depending on the brand of margarine.
We can’t get white choc chips here… Can you tell me what weight in white chocolate I would need
What can’t I use Peppermint Extract in the Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge?
You can, it will just taste like peppermint instead of Mint chocolate ice cream.
Made it and DELICIOUS!!! Not quite as pretty as yours, as my mini chocolate chips melted slightly, so there’s a bit of chocolate ribbons mixed into the green. Nevertheless, it’s great!
Thanks for this recipe! I improvised a little, using a mix of peppermint extract and a teeny bit of vanilla since the store didn’t seem to have regular mint extract. Looks good, hopefully tastes good too!: 🙂
Hiya just want to clarify measurements, is 3 1/4 = 3 and 1/4 cups? and is 3/4= three quarters of a cup? Thanks suzanne
Yes, you are correct.
Hi,
My friends and i would like to try out making the mint chocolate chip fudge but however in our country its kinda hard to get mint extract. will it be ok if we use peppermint extract instead ? though i know u stated (not peppermint extract). How will it taste like if we use peppermint extract ?
You can certainly use peppermint extract, just remember, it will taste more like a peppermint candy cane than Mint chocolate chip ice cream. I would also change out the food coloring to a few drops of red, for a pretty pink color.
THAT LOOKS LIKE SOME YUMMY SHIT RIGHT THUR LADY!!!
I made this and it turned out fine..except I needed to add 2 tbls. Of butter flavored shortening to make the white chips smooth and creamy..make sure it’s cooled as much as possible before adding the.mini chips. ..it did require a little extra TLC while making it..My friends and family loved it.
I tired this recipe over the weekend and triple checked the measurements but my mixture came out “Soupy” . I thought maybe there was too much condensed milk but I used one can 14oz. carnation condensed milk.
But I see that the instructions say that the mixture needs to be pushed intot the pan but mine was so liquid that I tired freezing it but it was more “gooey” frozen than fluffy and firm.
Any suggestions…I really like the taste of the liquid I just need to get it to better consistency.
Michael, did you use sweetened condensed milk? Or did you use evaporated milk? Sweetened condensed milk comes in a can and is very thick and sweet. Eagle Brand from Borden is what you want.
This recipe looks delicious and I am excited to make it for Christmas gifts!
Just wondering how you measure your “3 1/4 cup white choc chips” and “2 tablespoons of butter”.. Are you precise with these measurements? (I live in New Zealand and we typically use grams/metric)
Thanks and Merry Christmas from NZ!
I tried the recipe but my version came out very liquidy. Not fudge like. I had to put it in the freezer but it still seemed too soft.
ANy suggestions? should I use less condensed milk?
Hi, thank you for the recipe! I made it and it tastes great! I did not use chocolate chips. It came out very sticky, did I use too much milk? What should I do to make it set better? It will still get eaten! Looking forward to trying again! Thanks!
If you didn’t use chocolate chips, what did you use in place of them?
I cannot find mint flavoring – any suggestions? Really want to try this.
Can I use mint chocolate chips instead of the white chocolate chips and mint extract? I am having problems finding mint extract.
Sure you can, I love the mint chocolate chips!
I just made this and the mini chocolate chips melted when I stirred them in
So sorry this happened for you. You need to let the fudge batter cool a bit before stirring in the mini chocolate chips. I’m sure it still tasted great!
Is this fudge soft?
Yes, this is a soft, melt in your mouth fudge. Enjoy!
Hi Joan,
When I added the Condensed milk to my melted chocolates it became very soupy. Should I add less condensed milk? Has this happened to anyone else?
Please help!
Did you use the full 3 and 1/2 cups of white chocolate chips? This should be nothing close to soupy. I’m so sorry it turned out like that for you.
same thing happened to me? not sure what I did wrong
Michael did u use sweetened condensed milk? that was my mistake…. I used 2% condensed milk lastnight and it turned out soupy. I re read the ingredients today and realized what I did wrong! it turned out great tonight 🙂 great recipe!!
I made this yesterday and it tasted fantastic. I couldn’t get it to firm up, what did I do wrong?
I’m so sorry it didn’t turn out for you, did you check the ingredients and use the full 3 and 1/4 cups of white chocolate chips?
Hi I’m from North Queensland ( Australia ) I haven’t been able to Find mint extract anywhere 🙁 Would you possible know where I could buy it from ?
is there anything I can do to fix it?
Thanks for the recipe!! Looks wonderful
would this work with bakers chocolate? Chocolate chips tend to be oily
Also tip when melting chocolate chips in microwave you should do so at medium low setting rather then on high (I always set to 5-6 at 1 min intervals stirring in between until melted). Doing so will avoid the previous problems posted with the chocolate becoming “chunky” and “lumpy”
My wife and I just made this, but we did not wait long enough for it to cool down before folding in the mini chocolate chips. Now it’s swirled mint chocolate fudge. Still delicious though!
Swirls are pretty too!
hay joan.
so heres the deal. i followed your recipe to a tee especially after reading the comments. used the exact measurements (i have baking OCD)and i did this today 16/12/2014 at 3:15 pm. been checking on it every two hours but still hasn’t set and its 12:05 17/12/2014. i need help/advice i was gonna gift them to friends xxx TIA
My suggestion is for those in high altitude: to avoid a fudge that won’t set up, use Crisco instead of butter, and remove 2 tablespoons of the sweetened condensed milk before adding to chocolate chips. If you have an aversion to Crisco, use half the butter.
thanks for the tips!
Turned out perfect! The only difference is I melted the butter in a separate pan and then added the mint extract to that. I was nervous about cooking in the microwave so I did the double broiler method and added the melted butter and mint first and the stirred in the chips and it mixed very nicely! First batch I too did not wait long enough before folding in the chips but it turned out pretty anyways. Second batch I waited almost 10 minutes before folding them in and that worked great! Wonderful recipie, sure to be a Christmas goody gift hit!
I’m a huge mint chocolate chip fan! Thanks for linking up at Best of the Weekend!
Oh, the Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge looks so good!
Hi Joan! Your Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge is featured at our Simple Supper Tuesday Linky Party at Moore or Less Cooking Food Blog! Nettie
http://mooreorlesscooking.com/2015/03/09/simple-supper-tuesday-linky-party-52/